After the bachelor’s degree: Follow up with a master’s or go straight into the job market?
When we are about to finish our undergraduate degree, one doubt that emerges is whether we should continue our studies or go straight into the job market. In addition to all the external pressure, it is essential to think about ourselves and what we truly want. Just like other decisions in our lives, this one is very demanding, so we must understand what weighs more in the balance: our passion or the immediate and future advantages/disadvantages.
Qualitative research findings:
After interviewing a student who is pursuing a master’s degree in economics and another who is now applying for a master’s in marketing management, their experiences show that there are usually more students who decide to continue studying. One of the possible reasons we found is the student’s passion, because as was mentioned in one of the conversations, a master’s degree should only be taken if we want to specialize in a particular area and learn even more about it.
Equally important is the choice of the right university, as it has a significant influence on the course of our experience. In addition, it was also reported that if we want to try another university, there are more academic advantages in doing so between the first and second cycles than between the second and third cycles, since we will already know professors in the areas where we want to do research.
Firms’ preferences:
In Portugal, the preference of companies to hire individuals with a bachelor’s vs. master’s degree is one of the main concerns of students. Although both educational paths offer distinct advantages, the choice is often accompanied by a concern not only regarding salary issues and career trajectory, but also the ability to enter the job market.
Following the introduction in 2006 of a 3-year undergraduate degree instead of the 5 years that used to be required to complete this cycle of studies, within the Bologna process, bachelor’s and master’s degrees now last 5 years as a whole. Someone with a master’s degree is often more appealing to companies. They are seen as a safer option because they are better educated and have completed a longer period of study, already have a specialization and are more mature in their work. For these reasons, these professionals tend to demand a higher salary than someone without a master’s degree.
In turn, those with a bachelor’s degree are seen as a less experienced Human Resource, because, when they enter the job market, companies know that they have little or no experience beyond university and/or associations. However, this is not necessarily a negative thing. Many companies prefer these kinds of candidates, as they allow for more on-the-job training, enabling professionals to acquire the necessary and often more specific knowledge for a particular position/career. These professionals usually have lower entry-level salaries than someone with a master’s degree, but is the difference really meaningful?
Salary comparison:
The average salary of young workers aged between 25 and 34 who have a master’s degree has fluctuated significantly over the last decade, so it is natural to wonder whether having a master’s degree is more advantageous from a purely monetary point of view than a bachelor’s.
In 2020, the average salary of young workers with a master’s degree (between the ages of 25 and 34) was 1669 euros, which is around 22% more than that of workers in the same age group who only had a bachelor’s degree. Nevertheless, this difference varies according to the profession. In some professions, those with a master’s degree earn, on average, 35% more than someone with a bachelor’s degree.
On the other hand, there are also professions where the average salary is similar for both cases. Interestingly, there are even professions where bachelor’s graduates have higher salaries on average than graduates, but these cases are becoming more and more of a minority. In fact, in 2020, master’s degree holders had a salary differential over bachelor’s degree holders in 86% of the professions where higher education was required.
Figure 1 – Average gross salary of young workers in 2021
Youth unemployment rate:
Strictly considering the first graph below, in 2019 the unemployment rate for recent graduates, i.e. with a master’s degree (8.99%), was higher than for those with only a bachelor’s degree (3.67%) in the social and behavioral sciences field. With respect to more recent information, in 2022, the unemployment rate for undergraduates was 3.33%.
In the areas of business sciences and mathematics and statistics, due to data limitations, it is only possible to assess the data for undergraduates. Thus, in 2022, there was an unemployment rate for new entrants with a bachelor of 3.97%, in the area of business sciences, and 1.52%, in the area of mathematics and statistics.
Figure 2 – Evolution of the percentage of recent graduates registered as unemployed in the Social and Behavioral Sciences field (2014-2022)
Figure 3 – Evolution of the percentage of recent graduates registered as unemployed per field (2014-2022)
Conclusion
In summary, not only is it key to take into account personal passion and the desire to grow academically, for example by wanting to pursue research or a PhD, but we must also consider measurable factors such as companies’ preferences, salaries or the unemployment rate in the areas we wish to pursue. We should not forget that these factors have a significant impact on individual success and well-being, both immediately and in the long term.
References
https://www.joseneves.org/artigo/salario-maior-para-quem-tem-mestrado
https://brighterfuture.joseneves.org/area/46/Matematica-e-estatistica/0
https://brighterfuture.joseneves.org/area/34/Ciencias-empresariais/0
https://brighterfuture.joseneves.org/area/31/Ciencias-sociais-e-do-comportamento/0